Porsche
Cayman
Porsche
911
Porsche Cayman vs 911: Which Performance Icon Fits Your Drive in Marietta, GA?
Choosing between the Porsche Cayman and 911 is like deciding between two distinct driving philosophies—both thrilling, but built for different priorities. Whether you crave balance and precision or heritage and horsepower, both models deliver the legendary Porsche experience.
In our head-to-head comparison of the Porsche Cayman vs. 911: The Cayman offers sharper handling, better fuel economy, and lower entry pricing, while the 911 brings more power, added versatility, and iconic status with supercar-like performance.
With decades of Porsche expertise and deep roots in the Marietta and greater Atlanta driving community, we’re here to help you make the best call for your garage and lifestyle. In this guide, we’ll break down performance specs, driving feel, interior features, and value insights so you can confidently decide between these two engineering masterpieces.
Let’s take a closer look at what truly separates the Porsche Cayman vs 911—and which one belongs in your driveway.
Summary
- The Cayman is built for pure driving enjoyment, offering lighter weight, mid-engine balance, and a lower cost of entry—ideal for first-time Porsche buyers or track enthusiasts.
- The 911 delivers higher performance, more tech, and 2+2 seating, making it the better pick for daily use, longer road trips, or those who want ultimate Porsche prestige.
- In the Porsche Cayman vs 911 decision, the right choice depends on your priorities—whether that’s precision and value or unmatched performance and versatility.
A Quick Comparison of the Porsche Cayman vs. the Porsche 911
- +79 HP advantage in the base 911 over the base Cayman — quicker off the line and stronger across the powerband.
- +0.7 seconds faster 0–60 mph for the 911 Carrera — more immediate acceleration for those seeking supercar-level performance.
- +11 mph higher top speed for the 911 base model — better for high-speed touring or spirited weekend drives.
- +2 trim levels and more variant diversity in the 911 lineup — from Carrera to GT3 RS, the 911 offers more personalization and performance ceilings.
- ++2 extra seats in the 911 — a 2+2 layout allows occasional rear passengers or more cabin utility than the Cayman's two-seat setup.
- +2.6 seconds faster 0–60 mph in top trims — the 911 Turbo S hits 60 in just 2.6 seconds, versus 3.8 in the Cayman GTS 4.0.
Gallery
Porsche
718 Cayman
Porsche
911
Feature Breakdown
Performance Showdown: 2025 Cayman vs 911 Specs Breakdown
| Feature | Porsche 718 Cayman | Porsche 911 | Dealership Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base Engine | 2.0L Turbo Flat-4 (300 hp / 280 lb-ft) | 3.0L Twin-Turbo Flat-6 (388 hp / 332 lb-ft) | The 911 outpaces the Cayman in straight-line speed, but the Cayman remains sharp and engaging for daily Marietta driving. |
| Top Performance Trim | GTS 4.0 - 394 hp / 317 lb-ft (NA Flat-6) | Turbo S - 640 hp / 590 lb-ft | The Cayman vs 911 performance gap widens at higher trims, with the 911 delivering supercar territory specs. |
| 0-60 MPH (Fastest Model) | 3.8 seconds (GTS 4.0) | 2.6 seconds (Turbo S) | 911 wins on acceleration, but the Cayman still thrills thanks to weight and balance. |
| Top Speed | 171 mph | 191 mph | If top-end speed is a priority, the 911 provides a clear edge. |
| Fuel Economy (Base) | 21 city / 27 hwy | 18 city / 25 hwy | Better fuel economy in the 718 Cayman, making it more efficient around Atlanta commutes. |
| Transmission Options | 6-Speed Manual / 7-Speed PDK | 7-Speed Manual / 8-Speed PDK | Both offer exceptional transmissions, but Cayman's manual feels more connected to purists. |
When it comes to raw numbers, the 911 outpaces the Cayman in horsepower, acceleration, and top speed across the board. But the Porsche 718 Cayman vs 911 comparison is about more than stats—it’s about how that power is delivered, and for many drivers, the Cayman’s lighter build and naturally aspirated GTS 4.0 trim offer a purer, more visceral connection to the road.
For Georgia drivers who favor balance over brute force, the Cayman represents performance precision, while the 911 delivers prestige-tier punch with a broader engine lineup.
On the Edge: Porsche Cayman vs 911 Handling Compared
| Feature | Porsche 718 Cayman | Porsche 911 | Dealership Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engine Layout | Mid-Engine | Rear-Engine | The Cayman's mid-engine setup delivers better balance for twisty roads near Marietta. |
| Weight Distribution | 45:55 | 52:48 | Cayman offers neutral handling, while 911 gives rear-biased power dynamics for skilled drivers. |
| Wheelbase | 97.4 inches | 96.5 inches | A shorter wheelbase helps Cayman turn faster, ideal for Morrow or city streets. |
| Cornering Grip | High; neutral & predictable | Very high; demands experience | The 911 is more capable at the limit, but Cayman is easier to control at speed for less experienced drivers. |
| Suspension | PASM + optional adaptive damping | PASM + rear-axle steering (standard on higher trims) | 911's rear-wheel steering aids high-speed control, while the Cayman feels more connected at lower speeds. |
| Ride Character | Agile, taut, responsive | Stable, smooth, composed | If you're looking for track-day fun, choose the Cayman. For touring comfort, the 911 wins. |
In this Cayman vs 911 comparison, the Cayman’s mid-engine layout and lower curb weight create a near-perfect balance, especially in tight curves and low-speed corners around Marietta or the North Georgia foothills. It’s nimble, responsive, and encourages confident driving—even for newcomers to the brand.
The 911 counters with high-speed stability, adaptive suspension, and rear-axle steering, giving it incredible poise on the open road. But it requires a more experienced hand to fully unlock its potential.
Cabin Experience: Porsche Cayman vs 911 Interior Highlights
| Feature | Porsche 718 Cayman | Porsche 911 | Dealership Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seating Configuration | 2-seater | 2+2 seating with rear jump seats | The 911 offers extra usability, especially for short family trips or extra storage space. |
| Cargo Volume | 15.0 cu-ft (dual trunk setup) | 4.8 cu-ft | Cayman dominates in cargo space, offering surprising practicality for a two-seater. |
| Interior Design | Driver-focused; minimalist | Luxurious with advanced tech | Porsche Cayman vs 911 interior is about purpose: focused vs flexible. |
| Infotainment | 10.9" Touchscreen w/ Apple CarPlay | 12.3" Touchscreen + Optional HUD + Bose Audio | The 911 edges ahead in tech integration, especially in higher trims. |
| Premium Touches | Optional leather & bucket seats (GT trims) | Massage seats, ambient lighting, Alcantara | 911 delivers true grand touring luxury, while the Cayman feels more intimate. |
| Ride Comfort | Stiffer and more engaging | Cushioned and refined | The Cayman is more sport-focused, whereas the 911 blends speed with comfort across long Georgia highways. |
The Porsche Cayman vs 911 interior comparison is a study in focus versus flexibility. The Cayman’s cockpit is built purely for the driver, with dual cargo areas and a clean, minimalist design that keeps your attention on the drive.
The 911 takes things a step further, offering rear seats (albeit compact), advanced infotainment options, and higher-end comfort features—making it a better pick for those balancing performance with daily drivability in and around Atlanta.
What You Get for the Price: Cayman vs 911 Value Insights
| Feature | Porsche 718 Cayman | Porsche 911 | Dealership Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting MSRP | $72,800 | $120,100 | The Cayman is the better value if you're entering the Porsche world for the first time. |
| Top Trim MSRP | ~$99,700 (GTS 4.0) | Up to $407,115 (GT3 RS) | The 911 commands a higher premium, but with broader trim options and unmatched prestige. |
| Maintenance Costs | Lower (fewer turbos, simpler build) | Higher (advanced tech and hybrid options) | Cayman offers a lower cost of ownership, especially for daily drivers. |
| Resale Value (5-Year Avg) | 50-55% | 60-70% | The 911 retains value better, especially among enthusiast collectors and premium buyers. |
| Warranty | 4-year / 50,000-mile | 4-year / 50,000-mile | Both models offer Porsche's industry-standard warranty coverage. |
| Value Proposition | Balanced, affordable, track-capable | Prestige, versatility, performance range | Cayman for purity and price, 911 for versatility and long-term luxury appeal in the best sports car segment. |
From a pricing perspective, the 718 Cayman undercuts the 911 by a wide margin, making it one of the best sports car values on the market. With lower maintenance costs and a more accessible entry point, it's a smart pick for performance-focused buyers who want to enter the Porsche family.
The 911 justifies its premium with unmatched brand cachet, stronger resale value, and a broader lineup ranging from daily driver to full-on track monster. If you're after long-term luxury and variety, it's a clear win.
Which Porsche Wins? Our Verdict on Cayman vs 911
If you’re after the best sports car for driver feel, balance, and engagement, the Cayman is the enthusiast’s choice. But for those who want more room to grow—whether in terms of power, prestige, or everyday usability—the 911 continues to define the segment.
At the end of the day, the Porsche Cayman vs 911 decision isn’t about right or wrong—it’s about what kind of driving experience speaks to you most.
Porsche Cayman vs 911: Frequently Asked Questions
Still deciding between the Porsche Cayman and 911? This FAQ breaks down the top questions we hear from Atlanta-area drivers—from performance and practicality to pricing and test drives—so you can make the right choice with confidence.
Which is faster: the Porsche Cayman or the 911?
The Porsche 911 is faster in every trim, with up to 640 horsepower and a 2.6-second 0–60 mph time in the Turbo S. The 2025 Cayman GTS 4.0 is no slouch, though—it hits 60 in 3.8 seconds and delivers track-ready performance with mid-engine balance.
Is the Porsche Cayman better for handling than the 911?
Yes—the Porsche Cayman’s mid-engine layout and lighter frame give it sharper, more neutral handling, especially on winding roads or mountain curves near Atlanta. It’s often considered the best sports car for pure driving engagement at its price point.
Can you daily drive a Porsche 911 around Marietta?
Absolutely. The Porsche 911 blends high-end performance with comfort and 2+2 seating, making it a practical daily driver even for Marietta commutes. Adaptive suspension and a quiet cabin make it surprisingly livable for everyday use.
Which offers better value: Porsche Cayman or 911?
The Porsche 718 Cayman wins on value, offering performance thrills, Porsche build quality, and long-term reliability at a significantly lower entry price. The 911 commands a premium, but it delivers more luxury, power, and long-term resale strength.
What’s the difference in interior features between the Cayman and 911?
The Porsche Cayman interior is sport-focused, with two seats and dual cargo spaces. The 911 interior offers more luxury touches, 2+2 seating, and advanced tech like massage seats and a head-up display, perfect for those who want comfort with speed.
Which Porsche model is best for first-time sports car buyers?
The Cayman is ideal for first-time Porsche owners looking for a nimble, responsive car that’s easy to drive and own. It’s a gateway into the brand without sacrificing thrills, especially popular with drivers across Morrow and greater Atlanta.
Can I test drive both the Porsche Cayman and 911 at Porsche Atlanta Northwest in Marietta, GA?
Yes! At Porsche Atlanta Northwest, we welcome you to compare the Porsche Cayman vs 911 side by side. Visit us at 2501 Windy Hill Rd SEMarietta, GA 30067-8663, or call (888) 801-6524 to schedule your personalized test drive today.
A Final Word on the Porsche Cayman vs. Porsche 911 Comparison
Now that you’ve explored the Porsche Cayman vs 911, it’s time to experience their unique personalities firsthand with a test drive.
Both models represent the pinnacle of German engineering, but they cater to very different kinds of driving passion. The Cayman delivers surgical handling and a purist's balance that’s ideal for winding Georgia roads or weekend track days, while the 911 offers an unmatched blend of power, prestige, and versatility that shines on long highway cruises or spirited drives through Atlanta’s scenic backroads. No matter which you choose, you’re stepping into an icon.
At Porsche Atlanta Northwest, we’re proud to serve performance enthusiasts from Marietta, Morrow, and the greater Atlanta area. Our knowledgeable team is here to guide you through every trim, feature, and option—so you can find the perfect Porsche that fits your lifestyle and driving goals.
Visit us at 2501 Windy Hill Rd SE, Marietta, GA 30067 or call 877-930-3824 to schedule your personalized test drive today. Let’s get you behind the wheel of something unforgettable.
How Can We Help?
* Indicates a required field